Tuesday, March 5, 2024
Fingerlooping along... (5 strand square and 7 strand flat)
Monday, March 4, 2024
Today's fingerloop braids
Well, so far. Maybe there will be more later today, though if so, I'll try to wait until at least tomorrow to inflict them on my imaginary audience.
This is a 7-strand braid. My fingers really did not want to cooperate in walking down loops! Dunno if that's because it's a 7-strand A-fell braid or because of the angle I held it at or my fingers just weren't having it.
This is a pigtail-type braid. The place I saw it described/explained was very careful to take the loops reversed in a particular direction. Hmmm. I tried reversing it in the other direction and not reversing it at all and it didn't seem to make any difference. Then I figured out that this was a braid called "A Lace Broad Party" and the instructions on silkewerk.com (from a saved version on archive.org) specifically mention that it makes no difference whether or not the loops get reversed. Hah. Dunno if it makes a difference with bi-color loops. Probably not, since no loops go through any other loops.
Anyway, this is apparently Tollemache 62 and thus a genuine historic braid. No loops get pulled through any other loops. The empty index finger picks up the pinky-finger loop from the other hand. The loops get lowered, repeat with other hand, etc.
It's pretty much the same thing I was doing with pigtail-style braids with 5 and 3 loops. And indeed, it can generalize to other numbers of loops, and it can also be done freehand, and can also be done by going through some loops while going under/over others.
It's a pretty cute braid, of course. But wow, I think I need to work on finger dexterity and finger independence!
Also, although I'm still playing around with 4- and 5-loop braids, I'm ready to also start exploring more braids that have more than 5 loops.
This yellow braid is actually 2 different braids. I changed about halfway through. They are both 4-loop braids.
The first one is from a handout I apparently found online somewhere. It is from Eowyn de Wever, "Fingerloop Braiding; A sampler of four braids on 8 loops and 2 colours", from a class that she taught at some point since these are referred to as class notes.
The braid I did is "The Square Braid on 4 loops." This is supposed to be a helpful transition braid between an 8-loop spiral and a barleycorn-type braid.
I did that for about half or a bit more than half of the length of the braid, then got tired of dropping loops and my fingers not wanting to move loops around.
The second half of the braid is from The Weaver's Journal 37, Summer 1985. There's an article in there by Noemi Speiser, "Unusual Braids Produced by Loop Manipulation", p.15-18, 67-73. A lot of it is about the joys of track plans. Luckily she includes the basic fingerloop manipulations as a guide for how the plans correspond to the braids. I mean, I do understand what the track plans represent. But I'm still having trouble backing out the finger/loop movements from only the track plan. Clearly I need to practice more and do a few exercises in working with both the track plan and the fingerloop diagrams at the same time, or taking the one and generating the other, or both.
The braid I did is the 4-loop braid from Figure 8 on p.70. It was a lot more satisfactory than the first braid, not nearly as annoying to do. Speiser says that this braid was found on "an old European purse."
I'll have to try these again using loops of different colors. I may also switch the pigtail braid to V-fell to see if it's less annoying that way.
It's kind of fun to see how the two yellow braids look relatively similar (as monocolor braids) even though they have different structures. Also, the Speiser braid tends to spiral.
Each braid has 3 faces, I think. For the Speiser braid, they are all Vs or herringbones. For the de Wever braid, there are 2 faces of Vs/herringbones and one that looks sort of like the flat face of a 3-loop flat braid (i.e. it shows interlacements).
All of these braids were meant as samplers/experiments, which is part of why the tension is inconsistent. Well, part of it was general new-braid and finger-dexterity awkwardness. But I really did want to see what the 7-loop Lace Broad Party looked like at different tensions.
I'd also like to work through the rest of the braids in the Speiser article as well as doing the braid in the connected article by Adele Cahlander on p. 15-16, "Detective Story: Unraveling the Mystery of a 7-loop braid." Which also means I need to go back through her sling-braiding books/articles to look for fingerloop braids. The last time I really looked at them, I was more interested in the square braids that are done freehand or on a marudai.
And alas, there's nothing about fingerloop braiding in the few things I have, including her book on Sling Braiding in the Andes. Harumph. I don't recall anything about fingerlooping in the book referenced in the article. The book referenced by Cahlendar was that Andean knitting book by Cynthia LeCount, and in particular, the strap on a Bolivian monedero. As I recall, most of LeCount's book was about the amazing knitted chullos. I'll have to see if I own that book and if so, if anything is said about the strap or about braiding in general.
Inspired by the above, I did a few more samplers.
I tried to do a 3-loop braid, going through 0 loops, taking the loops alternately above and below the uninvolved loop. I don't know if I was messing up or what, but I kept undoing what I'd just done. Frustrating. Similar for going through 2 loops while taking the moving loop reversed on one side and unreversed on the other. It's apparently difficult to count to 3 and/or keep my fingers straight as to which is the operator loop, which is the moving loop, and what happens to loop between the two. Or it just ends up not looking very interesting. Sigh.
So I added a fourth loop and played again. That was more successful!
It's hard to see, but first I did a combo 3-5 square braid, using V-fell braiding, inspired by Ingrid Crickmore's mention of the 6-loop braid done as a combo 5-7 square braid. For one hand it was like a 3-loop braid and the other hand was like a 5-loop braid. I took both loops reversed. Yes, success! It is a perfectly lovely little braid with a triangular cross-section, easy to do as long as I can count to two. Two sides have herringbone Vs and the third shows a small, neat interlacement.
Then I took the loop reversed for the first move (when my operator finger went through 1 loop on the other side) and unreversed for the second move (when my operator finger went through 2 loops on the other side). This makes a nice little flat braid, yay! There are 2 Vs on each side.
Then I did the opposite -- taking the loop unreversed when going through 1 loop, taking it reversed when going through 2 loops. This does not make a flat braid. It's similar to the first, a triangular cross section, though I think all three sides are Vs and none show an interlacement.
Finally, since there wasn't much length left, I did the 4-loop spiral braid, varying whether I reversed loops and also varying which loop went through which loop (i.e. always the right loop on the outside, reversing the left loop, versus always the upper finger loop on the outside, reversing the lower finger loop). They're subtly different but not enormously so, as I think I already knew.
Dunno what I'll do next, but I have a lot of potential things to try. Plus there are some tablet weaving things I want to play with. And I'm vaguely feeling the urge to pull out the marudai. But I'll probably keep fingerlooping for a while even if I do start something else.
Sunday, March 3, 2024
Fingerlooping -- a few things I want to think about
A quick and not very exciting post....
I only have this one braid for a pic. It's a basic 3-strand round braid, one strand each of orange, purple, and blue. I think I did it with an A-fell method, but it might have been a mixed method. In other words, the index finger was the operator finger, and I picked up the middle-finger loop from the other hand, but I can't remember which of the loops the operator finger went through before picking up the traveling loop. Whatever. It makes a minimal difference in the final braid as long as I'm consistent, which I think I was.
I had set out to do a flat 3-loop braid but kept messing up, sigh. So I switched to this easier one where I didn't have to pay as much attention. It still took me more tries than I should admit to braid consistently with the same moves each time.
-----------------------
There is nothing particularly interesting about this post, but I wanted to write down a few thoughts for consideration later. They're still incomplete/ignorant newbie thoughts which no doubt will seem laughable to real experts.
Things that might matter for fingerloop braiding (and variations to consider).
1. A fell, V fell, Slentre, Mixed, Kute-uchi, Freehand/Stand braiding styles.
I am not sure this matters much. Different finger/loop set-ups might be easier or harder to manipulate depending on finger dexterity and how many loops there are. For example, Ingrid Crickmore says that she likes V-fell since it's easier to add a loop on the thumb in fingerloop braids when the operator finger is the pinky finger rather than the index finger, which means that 9-loop braids are more easily done than with A-fell methods. For A-fell, it's easier for many people to use their index finger as the operator finger rather than ring finger or pinky.
The different methods tend to be more common in specific geographic regions. Some of this is no doubt due to technology transfer, when people learn how to make these kinds of braids from people who are from (or were exposed to) some other culture/region. Some is independent re-invention. I think the L-M BRIC newsletter said that some regions/cultures used a couple of different methods.
I suspect there may be some characteristic mistakes in fingerloop vs freehand/stand braiding, but I don't want to think about this just yet.
I don't know if/how braiding style interacts with the spinning/plying twist in the strands.
Not all braids can be fingerlooped.
2. Taking the loops reversed or unreversed, and also, in which direction they are reversed.
This is a pretty big one for some braids -- it can mean the difference between double, square/round, and flat-opening braids. It allows one to insert open loops or finish off with mini-braids, by changing things around during the start, middle, or end of the braids.
For other braids, it seems not to make much difference in the appearance of the braid, though if one is using bicolor loops it might make some difference. (which means that one can take loops reversed or unreversed to make interesting color patterns)
For some braids, it makes a subtle difference. I mean, it's a structural difference, sure, and will affect how color patterns turn out (especially for bicolor loops but also sometimes single color) but the appearance is only somewhat different at a casual glance rather than being really different.
One can mix which loops get reversed or not. For example, flat braids are reversed on one hand and unreversed on the other. Are there braids where some of the moves are reversed and some not?
Changing things mid-braid is possible, as discussed above. This is especially true for the braids where reversed/unreversed makes a big difference.
It looks to me like one can twist the loop in either direction. Does this make a difference? Is it affected by the ply/spin direction of the threads? Can/should one vary this, either by which hand does what or by turns or randomly?
Which way to reverse the loop is somewhat dependent on the braiding style, maybe -- it sometimes seems easier to hook around the bottom or over the top for a particular braid and hand/finger set-up in order for a loop to reverse. I believe there are also braids that give the loop a full 360 degree twist rather than 180.
It's also very possible (and desirable) to do different things with each hand (or finger), so that some loops are taken reversed and some not, or taken reversed for one hand and not the other, or for some moves and not others. The square/split/flat braids are an example of this (one hand reversed and one not). So are the barleycorn braids, I think (some braiding moves that reverse, and the lateral exchange which can be either reversed or unreversed, I believe).
3. Which and how many loops are entered before the operator finger picks up the traveling loop.
This is the big one for a lot of braids. Of course. It's a big part of how one can get a whole family of braids from X number of loops.
One can go through 0 loops, 1 loop, 2, etc., up to all of them.
If one doesn't go through all of the loops, one's operator finger can skip over or under some of them on the way to the traveling loop.
If one skips over some of them, it can make a difference which ones get skipped over and which way they get skipped over (under or over).
Is this going to be consistent along the braid, or for one hand and not the other, or changing up and down the braid for various purposes?
Does it matter which way one enters the loops before picking up the traveling loop?
4. Loop exchanges (aka lateral exchanges).
Loop exchange braids keep the loops in pairs and swap them. This too has a few variations.
Which loop is on the outside -- does it alternate, is it always the same for each hand or each color, etc.?
Are the loops taken unreversed or reversed?
What if one changes the loops by simply swapping the positions rather than loops going through each other? (I seem to recall that one ends up with a lot of independent twisted strands.)
The order in which the loop-exchanges happen is also a factor. This too can change throughout the braid.
5. Moving loops without working them.
This, I suppose, is partly included in the above categories (going through 0 loops, swapping positions, etc.)
But... I've done that one braid (the 4-loop Guajiro one) that has one move loops from one finger to another finger, on the same hand, before doing the next bit of movement of loops between hands (which involves loops going through each other).
So... if the loops are moved without working them, it should come up with something similar to a freehand braid that is done with pairs of threads, right? But it gets more complicated with a mix of moving and looping-through.
And again, it makes a difference how the loops move, and over/under which other loops, and possibly whether or not they get twisted when they move.
6. Colors/textures.
Obviously one can do all kinds of fun things with color and texture -- all strands the same, some strands different, some strands bicolor/mixed-texture, etc. Plus there are ways to switch around in mid-braid in addition to a braid that is consistent throughout its length.
I will at some point carefully read Ingrid Crickmore's page on how to plot this out. She gives instructions she's already worked out for several braid structures. For those that aren't worked out and/or aren't easy to figure out, if and when I am willing to do the work, I can set up a bi-color loop sequence and work it out for myself.
7. Multi-person braids and braids using kute-uchi (though I think a lot of the kute-uchi braids can be done with fingers/hands). I haven't even begun to consider these yet.
8. Do I care about track plans? Noemi Speiser sure does. I haven't decided yet. Also, would it help for me to learn a bit about the mathematics of braids, especially as a way to describe/categorize them? Again, I haven't decided. I'll have to see what mathematicians care about and see how it intersects with what I care about. What are good methods with which to record braids, while being as unambiguous and specific as possible?
9. Which fingerloop braids correspond to which kumihimo or freehand braids? The structure of a braid doesn't necessarily tell you how it was made, especially if you only have a bit in the middle to look at. But it's fun to know several different methods for accomplishing the same thing, so one can do whatever seems most suitable given one's needs/wants at the time.
10. History, teaching, etc. How do I find out more about cords/braids throughout history/archaeology/anthropology? What, if anything, do I want to teach to others? There's also the related thing of braid characteristics and their uses throughout time. For example, some braids may be stronger/weaker and/or more/less elastic, grippy, etc., than others, more suitable for different fibers and sizes, more useful as pursestrings or ropes or fabric edges, etc.
So, that's just a few beginning thoughts based on my limited-so-far explorations. I might add more to this later as I think of or encounter more variables. Humans are so endlessly inventive; it's very cool to see what others have come up with, in addition to which ones they tend to keep and use most often.
Friday, March 1, 2024
Another 5 loop braid experiment
Yeah, more photos that all kind of look alike, too indistinct to make out details, and full of extraneous/confusing spots, such as when a loop got dropped and put back on the finger backwards, or a short experimental section that went very wrong, or inconsistent tension because I didn't care and didn't have a good anchor point, or a cat tried to help at various points.
And yet, informative for me, which is why I'm writing this down as a way to remember what I did and why.
Yeah, I know these are a trifle hard to see. These are from Jean Leader's fingerloop braid seminar done for the Braids and Band groups.io mailing list in 2021. In particular, these are from Part 3: Some More Braids.
On the handout, she has a couple of braids that are classified as "5-loop braids with some loops missed." She shows one where the loops are taken with no turns, and then one where the loops are taken reversed (i.e. with turns). She has various color patterns as examples, and I chose the variation with 5 bi-color loops, with color A on top and color B on bottom for all 5 loops.
These are all done in the A-fell method, by the way. Loops are on abc on one hand and bc on the other. The operator finger a goes through the loop on b (on the same hand), skips over the top of loop c (on the same hand) and then picks up the loop on c of the other hand. Walk down the loops and repeat.
So... The first braid is taken with loops unturned. The front and back are similar - each looks like a single column of knit stitches (or a V or a herringbone, I guess), with color A on one side and color B on the other. Now that I've finished the braid and looked at it more closely, I guess there's a bit of a ditch on the color A side (the color that was the top color of the loops) but it's not hugely obvious. The overall braid shape is oblong, slightly parallelogram-shaped or trapezoid-shaped in the cross-section with the edge thread of the bottom showing slightly along one side of the top.
For grins, I then did 5 moves with crossed loops, and then resumed the uncrossed loops. This was kind of fun -- as planned, color A was now on top and color B on the bottom, with the subtle ditch on the B side.
Then I switched to doing the all-crossed loop braid, where the loop is always taken reversed. This means that color A and B switch sides as they circle around the fingers on both hands. This also looks like the classic Broad Lace of 5 bows, with the ditch on the bottom now opened up more to show the flat interlacement of the loops, with the top looking like 2 Vs and being rather convex/curved. The center V of the top is higher than the 2 threads on each side, if that makes sense. It really does look like the ditch/groove on the bottom just opens up and flattens out the braid overall, making it shorter and wider.
Then I did the thing where I took the loop reversed with one hand and un-reversed with the other. It looks pretty similar to the first braid but with the bottom a little more opened up so the ditch is more visible. It does not become a flat braid the way the the square braid does.
OK, now it's time for V-fell, though I did a little bit of braiding while not going through any loops besides the moving loop to make sure I wasn't going to unbraid everything the way that Ingrid Crickmore warns us about. I did a bit by taking the other-hand loop c above the loops, and some by taking it under. I'd like to re-do this because it looks like one of them (the taking-the-loop-under) has an interesting interlacement pattern on top with a herringbone on the bottom, and it appears slightly fatter than the one done by going over the top. Dunno...
I switched to V-fell, with a few fumbles until my fingers caught the pattern again.
Loops were on fingers abc on one side and ab on the other. The empty c finger went through the other c, skipped b, and picked up a. I think. Argh, maybe I skipped c and went through b! If so, the following maybe not be applicable!
I did the same thing as before -- loops unreversed, loops reversed, one hand reversed and the other unreversed.
Ingrid Crickmore's triangle braid is one of these, the one with loops reversed. It does look slightly different from the other braids. Not significantly so, but somewhat if one really takes a look at it vs the A-fell equivalent. (though I must remember that I might not have skipped over the same loop for the A-fell and V-fell braids)
Conclusions -- these are all cute braids and easy to do. For all of them, the bottom is wider than the top. They are all pretty easy to do. They're all relatively similar-looking at first glance, with the difference being how obvious the groove in the bottom is and how much it spreads out. It's interesting that there's not a ton of difference in how the braid looks, at first glance and not counting the color pattern, whether both hands to the same moves or if each hand does something different (reversed vs un-reversed).
With the unreversed-turn braids, I like the idea of being able to switch colors more or less at will by doing 5 moves with crossed loops to flip the colors.
I would like to repeat this experiment by changing out whether the loop closest to the moving loop gets gone through or gone over. (in other words, for v-fell, do I go through c, over b, and pick up a, or do I go over c, through b, and pick up a). I'll probably do it with 5 different single-color loops instead of bi-color loops. Or maybe 10 different colors if I'm feeling very ambitious, to really see the path of each thread.
But on the whole, this was an enlightening set of experiments on the difference various factors make in a 5-loop braid where some loops are missed.
Thursday, February 29, 2024
Leap Day Fingerloop Braids
A few more fingerloop photos... Dunno if this is it for me for today or if I'll add to this post later (or put up another one tomorrow).
First is the sampler I did from 5 different colors of yarn (no bi-colors, though), that I mentioned yesterday. It's a bit hard to see, but I'll try to describe what I did.
Upper left -- this is the section where I treated each loop as its own unit, never pulling a loop through other loops. It's not really the same as a 5-strand pigtail, I don't think. It's flat, very similar-looking on both sides. The freehand 5-strand pigtail braid I do tends to look more square. So that's something for me to think about the next time I do freehand 5-strand pigtail braids. This one looks a lot like the braid I did with 3 loops when I did the same thing (i.e. the operator finger goes through 0 loops), except of course it's 5 loops instead of 3.
Then I did an inch or two of an A-fell square braid, with my index finger going through both loops on the same hand before picking up the loop on the ring finger of the other hand (through the bottom, to reverse it).
Then it was a small stretch of the D-shaped braid, A-fell, where my index finger goes through the middle finger loop and skips over the ring finger loop before picking up the ring finger loop on the other hand (reversing it). The part that shows in this photo is the flat side. The other side is flattish but not flat. It doesn't look quite like the square braid, but it has 2 Vs instead of the basketweave-like interlacing. I think this is what the old Medieval European sources call "a broad lace of v bows". Jean Leader calls it a "square 5 loop braid with some loops missed". Ingrid Crickmore calls it a "D-shaped braid".
On the bottom towards the left (after some less successful experiments) is a section of the square braid done as a flat braid, where one hand takes the loops reversed and the other takes them unreversed. I like this one a lot. Next time I do it, though, I'll try to tighten up the braid a bit better since it's lovely but a bit on the loose side.
I haven't tried the flat-braid method (i.e. one side reversed and one side not) with the D-shaped braiding technique. Maybe next time. And if so, I should see if A-fell looks different from V-fell.
This next one is the same as the 4-loop one I showed yesterday (Makusua Maize Blossoms, done by the Guajiro Indians of Columbia, from L-M BRIC 10), except with two colors. I tried the two color patterns that were suggested -- Vertical Strips and Helical Stripes. Although it's not easy to see, I also tried taking loops reversed vs non-reversed. Reversed vs non-reversed made almost no difference, similar to how it makes almost no difference when one does a 4-loop spiral braid where the loops exchange through each other.
This photo is of the other 4-loop fingerlooped braid presented in L-M BRIC 10 from the Guajiro Indians of Columbia. It is called Wayanatouya, which apparently means "a small piece of flat board", though the text then tells us that "we don't know the meaning of this name".
Masako Kinoshita writes, "This is a combination of two 4-element 2-ridge flat braids." She also writes, "This is a rare kind of braid that has two identical faces of 3 ridges with a S/Z/S-pattern. "
The top photo is monocolor, of course. The second one is done with two loops of each color, one in the "diagonal stripes" variation and the other in the "fish bones" variation.
This feels a lot like doing cat's cradle or another string figure! There are some moves where you're using your fingers to transfer loops from one finger to another on the same hand, much easier if it's assisted by fingers from the other hand.
The braid has a spiral to it, also. It's possible I was doing it wrong or that there are several ways to do it, some of which give a spiral and some which don't. Or that it's more pronounced in the worsted-weight acrylic I was using. Clearly more experiments will be necessary should I feel so inclined.
And so ends Fingerloop February 2024... It'll be interesting to see what I am inspired to do in March.
Wednesday, February 28, 2024
More February Fingerloop Braids
I keep forgetting to record and write down what I've been playing with lately. I have been busy with non-narrow-ware things, too, of course.
Here are a few of the recent braids.
This one is a plain 5-loop square braid (apparently this is "a round lace of five bows" in the Medieval European sources). I made it from something finer than #10 cotton, dunno if it was #20 or #30 or what. Wow, so fine! It took a lot longer than I expected based on how long the #10 takes. I was surprised at the thinness and gauge of the braid.
This next one is a new-to-me braid made from the instructions on this page: https://loopbraider.com/2017/08/07/uo-triangle-5-7-9tut/ I did the 5-loop variation because I'm doing 5-loop braids at the moment, mostly.
Except that Ingrid Crickmore sez that this is merely the V-fell version of the common D-shaped A-fell 5-loop braid. Hmm. It's like the square braid except that the operator finger only goes through 1 loop instead of 2 loops before picking up the traveling loop.
Dunno if she's right that it's the same structure or not. I'll have to redo this one in several colors of yarn and then do the A-fell version to see what I think. She discusses it (I'm not sure how accurately, but I don't have enough experience yet to assess it) here: https://loopbraider.com/uo-vfell-afell-mystery/
Since I've been thinking about different patterns of picking up, skipping, swapping, going through, reversing, etc., various loops in these braids, this inspires me to keep on experimenting.
This maybe does look a little bit different from the one I did with the A-fell method. It's still flat on one side and rounded on the other, but the flat side looks a bit different and more compact. Maybe. I need to make this again both A-fell and V-fell and try a few other things to see what differences there are, if any.
This last one in today's post is from L-M BRIC News Illustrated Instruction Series No. 10. It is a braid that is done by the Guajiro Indians from Colombia, as described by Marta R. Zapata. This braid is called Makusua, meaning maize blossoms. It has 4 loops, with each loop acting as a single element. Masaka Kinoshita writes this about it: "You may see this recipe as an application to the 1-m technique of the free-end method of making a 4-element round braid commonly seen the world over, that is, exchanging a pair of diagonally positioned elements one pair after the other."
It took me a little while to catch the rhythm of it, but it definitely sped up and got more consistent as I kept going.
There are two pairs of loops. Each pair swaps with itself but not with the loops in the other pair. It is not like the spiral braid because the loops do not go through each other.
I forgot to take a photo, but several days ago I also did a 5-loop braid with various methods (I changed every few inches).
If one never goes through any loops, then one gets something that looks like a 5-strand pigtail braid. I did the D-shaped braid that is supposedly the most common one in the world (one goes through one loop before picking up the loop next to it). I tried a few contortions to try some under-over-through variations, without too much success. And I did the flat 5-loop square braid (go through 2 loops, pick up a reversed loop with one hand and unreversed with the other). I quite like the flat braid. Hmm, I didn't try the flat braid with only going through 1 loop. Maybe that will be another experiment.
I should play around with planned color patterns at some point. I also want to look at the other 4-loop patterns in Noemi Speiser's Manual of Braiding.
I really need to start labeling my little experiments so I can remember which is which. The pile is growing.
The class I taught went well. I'll probably do another sometime in March -- the one I've already done on the 7-strand fill-the-gap disc braid.
















